What is syndicalism?
Syndicalism is a political and economic philosophy holding that labor unions, rather than a political party or the state, should organize workers to seize control of production directly, typically through a mass general strike, and then run the economy themselves through federated worker organizations.
Last reviewed . Not yet independently reviewed.
Core tenets
- Unions as the primary revolutionary vehicle
- Holds that labor unions themselves, not a political party or elected government, are the proper organization for workers to pursue economic and political change.
- Direct action
- Favors strikes, direct workplace organizing, and ultimately a general strike, over electoral politics or parliamentary reform, as the primary means of change.
- Worker control of production
- Envisions workers directly controlling and running industry through federated union structures, rather than through state ownership or private capital.
How it works in practice
Syndicalist movements have organized historically around industrial unions intended to unite all workers within an industry, regardless of specific trade or skill.
- Industrial unionism
- Organizes all workers within an entire industry into a single union, rather than dividing them by specific craft or trade, to build broader collective power.
- General strike
- A coordinated, economy-wide work stoppage is treated as the primary tool for forcing fundamental economic change, rather than negotiating incrementally.
Common variants
- Anarcho-syndicalism
- Combines syndicalist union organizing with explicit anarchist opposition to the state, aiming for a stateless, worker-run economy.
- Revolutionary syndicalism
- Focuses on unions as the vehicle for revolutionary change without necessarily adopting anarchism's specific opposition to all political organization.
What it is often confused with
Syndicalism is often confused with ordinary trade unionism, but its defining claim is that unions themselves should become the vehicle for seizing and running the entire economy, not simply negotiate wages and conditions with existing owners.
Criticisms and debates
Criticism of syndicalism centers on whether federated union structures can actually coordinate a complex modern economy without a broader political or state framework.
Coordination critique
Argues that a modern, complex economy requires coordination beyond what federated industrial unions alone can provide, particularly across different industries and regions.
Response: Syndicalist theorists respond that federated councils of unions, coordinating through congresses and delegated representatives, can in principle handle this coordination without a centralized state.
Marxist critique
Some Marxist theorists have argued that syndicalism underestimates the need for organized political power, specifically a revolutionary party, to defend gains made through general strikes against a hostile state.
Response: Syndicalists respond that relying on a party and state, rather than workers' own organizations, risks recreating the same concentrated authority syndicalism seeks to avoid.
Historical examples
- Confederation Generale du Travail, France, early 20th century
- A major French labor federation historically associated with revolutionary syndicalist strategy, including advocacy of the general strike.
- Industrial Workers of the World, United States, founded 1905
- An industrial union explicitly organized around syndicalist principles of direct action and industrial unionism.
Sources
- 1.Sorel, Georges. Reflections on Violence. 1908.
- 2.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Anarchism.
- 3.Encyclopaedia Britannica. Syndicalism.