What is anarchism?
Anarchism is a political philosophy that holds that the state itself, as a coercive, hierarchical institution, is illegitimate and unnecessary, advocating instead for voluntary cooperation and self-organized communities without centralized governing authority.
Last reviewed . Not yet independently reviewed.
Core tenets
- Opposition to the state as coercive hierarchy
- Holds that the state's authority ultimately rests on coercion rather than genuine consent, and that this makes it illegitimate regardless of how democratically it is organized.
- Voluntary association
- Favors organizing social and economic life through voluntary cooperation and mutual agreement, rather than through binding laws imposed by a governing authority.
- Opposition to imposed hierarchy generally
- Extends its critique of the state to other coercive hierarchies, with many anarchist traditions also opposing concentrated private economic power for similar reasons.
How it works in practice
Anarchist movements have organized in practice around decentralized structures intended to demonstrate that large-scale cooperation does not require a centralized state.
- Worker and community councils
- Decisions are made through directly democratic, decentralized bodies rather than a centralized government apparatus.
- Mutual aid networks
- Voluntary cooperative arrangements provide support and resources outside formal state welfare systems.
Common variants
- Anarcho-syndicalism
- Emphasizes organizing workers directly into unions as the vehicle for both resisting state and capital and organizing a stateless economy.
- Anarcho-communism
- Combines anarchist opposition to the state with communist opposition to private ownership, advocating voluntary, decentralized common ownership.
- Individualist anarchism
- Emphasizes individual sovereignty and voluntary exchange, more skeptical of collective economic arrangements than social anarchist traditions.
What it is often confused with
Anarchism is very often used in casual speech to mean simple disorder or chaos, but as a political philosophy it specifically advocates organized, voluntary cooperation without a centralized coercive state, not the absence of any social organization at all.
Criticisms and debates
Criticism of anarchism centers on whether large, complex societies can actually coordinate at scale without some centralized governing authority.
Coordination critique
Argues that large-scale infrastructure, defense, and dispute resolution require some centralized authority to function, and that purely voluntary arrangements cannot reliably scale to a modern society's needs.
Response: Anarchist theorists respond that federated networks of directly democratic councils can coordinate at scale without a centralized state, pointing to historical examples such as anarchist Catalonia as evidence, though critics dispute how durable or scalable these examples were.
Free-rider critique
Contends that without an enforcing authority, voluntary systems are vulnerable to individuals who take the benefits of cooperation without contributing to it.
Response: Anarchist responses vary by tradition, with some emphasizing strong social and community norms rather than legal enforcement as the mechanism for addressing this.
Historical examples
- Anarchist Catalonia, 1936 to 1939
- During the Spanish Civil War, anarchist and syndicalist organizations collectivized significant industry and agriculture in parts of Catalonia along anarchist principles.
- Paris Commune, 1871
- Cited by some anarchist theorists, alongside Marxists, as an early example of decentralized, working-class self-governance, though interpretations of its structure differ across traditions.
Sources
- 1.Kropotkin, Peter. Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution. 1902.
- 2.Bakunin, Mikhail. God and the State. 1882.
- 3.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Anarchism.
- 4.Encyclopaedia Britannica. Anarchism.