What is totalitarianism?
Totalitarianism is a form of government that seeks total control over both public and private life, using a comprehensive official ideology, a single ruling party, and extensive surveillance and coercion to eliminate independent institutions and organized opposition, distinguishing it from authoritarianism's narrower focus on concentrated political power alone.
Last reviewed . Not yet independently reviewed.
Core tenets
- Comprehensive official ideology
- A single, all-encompassing ideology defines and justifies the state's authority over essentially all areas of life, not only formal politics.
- Attempted control over private and civic life
- Independent civic organizations, religious institutions, and even family life are subject to state penetration and control, going beyond authoritarianism's focus on political power specifically.
- Single mass party
- A single party, often with a mass membership, serves as the primary vehicle for enforcing ideology and mobilizing the population, distinct from a narrower ruling clique.
- Systematic use of terror and surveillance
- Extensive surveillance, secret police, and often systematic violence are used to eliminate independent thought and organized opposition, not only political competitors specifically.
How it works in practice
Totalitarian systems have historically relied on mass mobilization and pervasive institutional penetration to achieve the comprehensive control the ideology demands.
- Mass party organization
- A single party organizes citizens into affiliated groups covering nearly every aspect of civic life, from youth organizations to labor unions, all under party direction.
- Comprehensive propaganda and censorship
- State control of media and education is used not merely to suppress dissent but to actively instill the official ideology throughout the population.
Common variants
- Fascist totalitarianism
- Combines totalitarian methods with an ultranationalist ideology, as historically seen in Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany.
- Communist totalitarianism
- Combines totalitarian methods with Marxist-Leninist ideology, as historically seen in the Stalin-era Soviet Union and Maoist China.
What it is often confused with
Totalitarianism is often used loosely as a synonym for any harsh authoritarian government, but the term's specific technical meaning requires the additional, comprehensive attempt to control private and civic life through a unifying ideology, not simply concentrated political power.
Criticisms and debates
Scholarly discussion of totalitarianism centers on how precisely the concept applies across different historical regimes, rather than a debate over its merits, since virtually no tradition defends totalitarian control as a positive ideal.
Conceptual-precision critique
Some political scientists, including later revisionist historians, have argued the totalitarianism concept was applied too broadly during the Cold War, obscuring real differences between, for instance, Stalin-era and later Soviet governance, or between Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy.
Response: Other scholars maintain the core totalitarian features, comprehensive ideology, single mass party, and systematic terror, remain analytically useful for describing specific historical periods precisely, provided the term is not applied indiscriminately to any authoritarian government.
Feasibility critique
Some scholars argue that truly total control over private life is never fully achieved in practice, even in the most extreme historical cases, since some private thought and informal resistance persist regardless of state effort.
Response: Proponents of the concept respond that totalitarianism describes the regime's aspiration and the extent of its coercive effort, not a claim that private thought is literally eliminated.
Historical examples
- Stalin-era Soviet Union, 1920s to 1953
- Widely cited as a defining example of totalitarian rule, combining a comprehensive Marxist-Leninist ideology, a single ruling party, and extensive use of terror and surveillance.
- Nazi Germany, 1933 to 1945
- Combined an ultranationalist and racial ideology with a single ruling party and extensive state penetration of civic and private life, a defining historical example of totalitarianism.
Sources
- 1.Arendt, Hannah. The Origins of Totalitarianism. 1951.
- 2.Friedrich, Carl J., and Zbigniew Brzezinski. Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy. 1956.
- 3.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Hannah Arendt.
- 4.Encyclopaedia Britannica. Totalitarianism.