What is a dictatorship?
A dictatorship is a form of government in which absolute or near-absolute political power is concentrated in a single leader or a small group, exercised without the meaningful, competitive elections or legal checks found in a republic or democracy.
Last reviewed . Not yet independently reviewed.
Core tenets
- Concentrated power
- Authority to make and enforce law rests with one person or a small ruling group, without an independent legislature or judiciary capable of overriding them.
- Absence of meaningful competitive elections
- Even where elections occur, they do not provide a genuine mechanism for removing the ruling power, whether because opposition is banned, results are controlled, or no real alternative is permitted to compete.
- Suppression of organized opposition
- Independent political parties, press, and civil organizations that could challenge the ruling power are typically restricted, co-opted, or banned outright.
- Personalization or centralization of authority
- Power is often tied closely to a specific individual or a tightly controlled inner group, rather than distributed across accountable institutions.
How it works in practice
Dictatorships vary in how power is actually organized and maintained day to day.
- Security and military apparatus
- Police, military, or paramilitary forces are typically central to enforcing the ruling power's authority and suppressing organized challenges to it.
- Patronage networks
- Loyalty from officials, military officers, and other elites is often secured through access to resources, position, or privilege controlled by the ruling power.
- Controlled information
- State control or heavy restriction of media and communication is commonly used to limit organized opposition and shape public perception of the ruling power.
Common variants
- Military dictatorship
- Power is held directly by military officers, typically installed through a coup, with the armed forces as the core institution backing the ruling power.
- Personalist dictatorship
- Power is concentrated around a single individual leader personally, rather than an institution, party, or military structure that could survive that leader's removal.
- One-party dictatorship
- A single political party controls the state, and formal political competition from other parties is banned or rendered meaningless.
What it is often confused with
Dictatorship is often used loosely as a synonym for any government someone dislikes, but the technical distinction is the absence of a genuine mechanism, competitive elections, an independent judiciary, or a free press, for removing or checking the ruling power.
Criticisms and debates
Discussion of dictatorship as a category mostly concerns how to classify borderline cases, rather than a live debate over its merits, since virtually no serious tradition defends dictatorship as such on principle.
Classification critique
Notes that many governments hold some, but not all, features of a dictatorship, such as holding elections that are neither fully free nor entirely fake, making sharp binary classification difficult in practice.
Response: Political scientists commonly respond by using graded or hybrid-regime categories, such as competitive authoritarian, rather than treating democracy and dictatorship as the only two available boxes.
Historical stability defense
Some historical apologists for specific dictatorships have argued that concentrated power can deliver order or rapid development that fragmented, competitive politics cannot.
Response: This argument is treated with skepticism by most contemporary political science and economics, partly because it is difficult to attribute development outcomes specifically to concentrated power rather than other factors, and because that same concentration removes the mechanism for correcting serious policy failures.
Historical examples
- Spain under Francisco Franco, 1939 to 1975
- A widely studied example of a personalist military dictatorship, with organized political opposition banned and power concentrated in Franco personally until his death.
- Chile under Augusto Pinochet, 1973 to 1990
- Installed by a military coup, commonly classified as a military dictatorship, with political parties banned and power held by a military junta.
Sources
- 1.Aristotle. Politics. Book V, on the causes and preservation of tyranny.
- 2.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Political Legitimacy.
- 3.Encyclopaedia Britannica. Dictatorship.