Communism vs Marxism
Communism vs Marxism, the short answer
Communism, in Marxist theory, is the final, classless, stateless stage of history; Marxism is the entire body of theory, historical materialism, class struggle, surplus value, that describes how history reaches that stage. Communism is the destination Marxist theory describes; Marxism is the map.
Last reviewed . Not yet independently reviewed.
What communism holds
Communism, in Marxist theory, is a final, classless, and stateless stage of historical development, in which the means of production are held in common and output is distributed according to each person's need.
- What it is: a described historical end-stage that Marxist theory arrives at, not a theory or an analytical method in itself.
- Ownership: common, held by society as a whole, with no private owners and no state apparatus administering them.
- Status: never implemented anywhere by Marx's own definition, since no self-described communist state has claimed to have reached it.
- Scope: a single specific outcome predicted within the broader theory, not the theory itself.
What marxism holds
Marxism is the body of theory developed by Marx and Engels, including historical materialism, class struggle, and surplus value, that explains how societies change and predicts communism as history's endpoint.
- What it is: an analytical framework and theory of historical change, not a single end-state.
- Ownership: not itself a claim about ownership, but a theory explaining why ownership structures change over time.
- Status: actively used today as a method of historical, economic, and social analysis, independent of any state's political system.
- Scope: the broader theoretical framework that communism is one predicted outcome of.
Where they overlap
The two terms are deeply linked, since communism is a claim that only makes sense within Marxist theory, but they are not interchangeable: one is a framework, the other is a specific predicted destination within it.
Communism is meaningless without Marxist theory
The specific claims that define communism, a classless, stateless, need-based final stage, only make sense as a conclusion of Marxist historical materialism and class analysis; the term has no independent definition outside that framework.
Both describe the same historical staging
Marxist theory and the communism it describes share the same underlying staged view of history, feudalism to capitalism to socialism to communism, with Marxism supplying the reasoning and communism naming the final stage.
Where they actually differ
| Axis | communism | marxism |
|---|---|---|
| Category | A described historical stage or outcome | A body of theory and method of analysis |
| Can be used analytically | No, it is the thing being described | Yes, used to analyze any society's class structure |
| Political movements named after it | Communist parties, pursuing it as a goal | Marxist parties or scholars, applying the theory more broadly, including academically |
| Real-world status | Never implemented anywhere, by Marx's own definition | Actively used today as an analytical framework in economics, sociology, and history |
Why they get confused
Communism and Marxism are used almost interchangeably in casual speech, since one is the best-known conclusion of the other, but they are different kinds of thing entirely.
Marxism is a theory: a set of claims about history, class, and economic structure that can be applied to analyze any society, including ones with no communist party or ambition whatsoever. Communism is one specific claim within that theory, a described future stage. A university course in Marxist analysis is not a course on how to build communism; it is a course on a method of historical and economic analysis, of which the prediction of communism is one part.
Sources
Sources here overlap heavily, since both pages draw on the same foundational texts.
- 1.Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. Manifesto of the Communist Party. 1848.
- 2.Marx, Karl. Critique of the Gotha Programme. 1875.
- 3.Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Karl Marx.
- 4.Encyclopaedia Britannica. Marxism.